OPINION: The state vs. the ostriches — Rules are rules, says food inspection agency
Nelson Zandbergen
Farmers Forum
Lack of evidence of sickness in the 300-plus doomed birds be damned.
What does the macabre mass shooting of those B.C. ostriches tell us about the Canadian Food Inspection Agency and its relentless push for this fatal outcome?
At the very least, it’s a stark illustration that the agency, as a human institution, is far from immune to the worst impulses of our species, possibly even as low as the social media Karens who gleefully celebrated the ostrich farmers’ loss and callously continue to disparage their real tears.
Some may disingenuously claim that a white-coated CFIA official was only dispassionately following the science, but the actions undertaken at the Edgewood, B.C., farm suggest bitter emotion as a key driver. The eager killing of the ostriches with the ink barely dry on the Supreme Court decision bears more than a passing resemblance to a seething vengeance and a triumph of a rules-are-rules sneering Karen-ism at an institutional level. As the gunshots rang out for several hours that night, does anyone doubt that at least some people inside the CFIA were deriving great personal satisfaction, if not pleasure, at the pain inflicted on the Universal Ostrich Farm operators that dared to defy them?
The die was likely cast last December when the owners didn’t themselves report what turned out to be an apparent H5N1 bird flu outbreak in their ostrich flock. Somebody else made the call, according to reports. It’s fair to say this would have pissed off people inside CFIA from the outset. When the owners then pushed back against the CFIA in court, in a bid to prevent the slaughter of their animals, this undoubtedly cemented the grudge against them and the agency’s bloody-minded pursuit of the ostriches’ demise. The owners had to be punished for their temerity.
A dispassionate and pragmatic scientific approach would have risen above the emotional impulse for vengeance-seeking. Once the legal process delayed matters long enough to make it obvious that the surviving ostriches were not sick with avian flu, the CFIA should have recognized the changed circumstances and accepted the situation was no longer even remotely analogous to a fresh outbreak at a commercial chicken barn containing tens of thousands of birds.
The CFIA could have easily accommodated the testing of the few hundred surviving ostriches to verify or disapprove their health, 10 or 11 months after they survived an apparent brush with the virus. There was no evidence of a continuing infection in the flock. And for all the bloviating about adhering to Canada’s international trade obligations, the CFIA could have exempted the ostriches from its ‘stamping out’ policy, just as it’s done at 14 outbreak sites since the latest iteration of bird flu arrived on North American shores in 2021. Six Royal swans in Owen Sound, Ontario, were saved by such an exemption in 2022. The CFIA’s refusal to budge on the ostriches demonstrates that settling scores took priority over science.
Of course, culling a whole flock or herd of animals can be necessary to prevent the spread of a pathogen that could threaten an industry if allowed to proliferate. When I was a kid, we lost our dairy herd to brucellosis. And who doesn’t remember the images of the Mad Cow response in the UK, with those enormous piles of Holstein carcasses burning in a farmer’s field? At least the British authorities had the courage of their convictions to show the public the gruesome consequences of their orders. Fast forward to 2025, and the CFIA behaves like it has a guilty conscience, trying to hide what happened on that ostrich farm, right down to the surreptitious disposal of the dead birds.
The CFIA obviously knows the ostrich cull was an embarrassing deviation from the otherwise justified destruction of almost 18 million poultry birds since 2021. Culls at poultry farms occur quickly after infection is discovered and often involve tens of thousands of birds that can’t be individually tested for logistical reasons. If left alone, the H5N1 virus would quickly rip through an infected chicken or turkey barn and kill almost all of the birds, an outcome the poultry industry for good reason wants to avoid as a trend in the countryside.
The ostrich farm was a completely different story and deserving of special consideration. The outbreak was long over and the majority of the birds survived, by the time the CFIA finally had them shot like a fish in a barrel. An ostrich is not a chicken, nor is it poultry, even if the law treats it as such. A horse and a naked mole rat are more closely related than an ostrich and a chicken, according to some online sources.
And to the Karens chortling on social media about people chowing down on chicken while being upset over the ostrich massacre: That chicken on the dinner plate was slaughtered for a useful purpose (food). It was slaughtered humanely and was slaughtered on the orders of the farmer that raised it. What transpired in B.C. was an affront to these norms.











































