A tough sell to farmers who don’t buy this save-the-climate illusion
LONDON — It was a tough, skeptical bunch that responded to the Ontario Ministry of Natural Resources’ (MNR) request for landowner feedback on plans for storing carbon dioxide in the rocks beneath our feet and farmland.
If MNR staff were looking for positive comment, they went home disappointed. The presenters found scant support for the effort to lock away this essential plant food in order to save the planet.
The MNR is currently working to develop a set of rules and regulations to shoot the carbon 800 metres below ground under high pressure and then cap it. The goal is to capture carbon dioxide and permanently inject it into depleted oil and gas wells or saline aquifers (salt beds) in order to meet Canada’s global commitment to Net Zero carbon emissions by 2050.
While there are thousands of such wells in Southern Ontario, the proposed storage area could reach far out under both Lake Erie and Lake Huron. While former OFA president Don McCabe supports reducing CO2, he expressed grave concerns about the effect that a storage failure would have on fresh water supplies and marine life. Another potential storage basin for CO2 is the vast expanse of Crown Land in Northern Ontario.
The Southern Ontario sites are especially attractive because of their proximity to heavy industrial emitters such as producers of cement, fertilizer, power generation and also petroleum refining facilities. One method of capturing carbon emissions is by injecting solvents into industrial smokestacks, causing the CO2 to separate and allow for containment.
The sequestered carbon could then be transported to the storage sites by truck, rail or pipeline. This triggered the question of why installing pipelines was okay for moving carbon, but not petroleum products that actually bring immense, tangible benefits to society.
Other reasons offered in favor of carbon capture and storage was the ability to attract industry and the prospect of many new, well-paying jobs. But that enticement conjured up reflections of the deadly, industry-crippling effect of the Kathleen Wynne era’s so-called green energy policy that drove electricity costs so high that it became economically beneficial for companies to leave Ontario. By moving across the border into the U.S., those companies gained access to surplus Ontario electricity at deeply discounted rates.
This raised the issue of determining how much “financial assurance” should be provided by the proponent to cover the cost of leakage, migration or damages, and when it should be paid into a mitigation fund. The “full cost” option seemed a little hazy as it would be quite challenging to determine the full cost of an unknown and unpredictable accident. Unsurprisingly, some pointed out that companies have been known to disappear at the hint of any liability.

Carbon dioxide bubbles in a soft drink.
As for private property rights, it would be the responsibility of the proponent to engage with the affected property owners and any other legal interests to evaluate the impact on their property. Also, the issue of deep pore space control was raised. Current examples of assumed jurisdiction were Alberta, where the province simply declared ownership of deep pore space. Also, B.C., gave itself the necessary rights to facilitate deep geological carbon storage beneath private property.
While the MNR presenters initially appeared to be messengers seeking input on a proposed scheme, by meeting’s end, CFFO director John Van Dyk unhappily opined that “this is a done deal.”
Perhaps the most supportive comment came from OFA’s Lambton-Middlesex director Crispin Colvin who said, “I want no part of this without a better education program.”
Beyond the meeting room doors and those who decried it as a needless response to a false dilemma, deep geological carbon storage has its share of critics pointing to technical and economic infeasibility. In other jurisdictions, it has suffered technical nightmares, soaked up massive government subsidies while giving negligible, global environmental benefit in return.
Reuters News, in a November, 2023 article entitled “Why carbon capture is no easy solution to climate change” says that carbon capture and storage is “…expensive, unproven at scale, and can be hard to sell to a nervous public…unworkable, at the moment…”
In even harsher tones, the International Energy Agency, a respected international body that provides data and analysis on all fuels and technologies, states that relying on carbon capture to reduce global CO2 emissions is “an illusion”.
However good the sales pitch for carbon capture and storage, Canadians are justifiably skeptical after having suffered under other presumptive climate change counter measures such as injurious green energy policies or carbon taxes. But we also know, today, that unpopular reality is not seen as a deterrent for chasing a popular but misguided illusion.
John Schwartzentruber is a Huron County farmer.











































