Farmers Forum
Nelson Zandbergen
NAPANEE — Ontario’s animal police recently investigated a Napanee horse farm and ordered the farmer to fill a single groundhog hole in a 50-acre horse pasture to protect the farm’s 20 horses. The taxpayer-funded inspector said she would return to see if the hole was filled.
Farm owner Amanda Dowdall says that Provincial Animal Welfare Services (PAWS) officers issued the order to “justify their visit” to the combined beef and horse-rescue-and-training farm in response to an anonymous complaint about the horses’ poor physical condition on May 13.
Dowdall diverts feral, young, unhandled and pregnant horses otherwise destined for Canada’s equine slaughter industry. She buys them at auction and rehabilitates and trains them for sale as riding horses. It’s a business and a passion, she says, having grown up as a rider. She does not contest that thin horses often arrive at the farm. That’s the whole point of rescuing them in the first place. They go into that lush 50-acre field, easily visible from Highway 2, to bring them up to a proper weight. But these newcomers attract the attention of the farm’s detractors, she said.
The complaint was followed by a May 13 visit from PAWS and its veterinarian. No animal health issues were identified so she was surprised to receive an emailed compliance order to fill the groundhog hole about one week later.
Dowdall is not pleased that anonymous complaints tie up their business. A few years ago someone fabricated a story and complained that they dragged a horse behind a truck, she said. In January, animal cruelty charges were withdrawn against Dowdall and her beef-farming husband, Ryan Leduc, due to lack of evidence.
In a previous dispute with animal welfare authorities, she and her husband pleaded guilty to a minor charge of having old hay bales, baler twine, and wood debris in their fields, paying a $500 fine and agreeing to a 100-horse capacity limit on their 450-acre farm just to put the stressful situation behind them. “In hindsight, we should have fought it because we would have won,” she said. “It was just all so ridiculous. But I wasn’t in a mental place to fight.”
Dowdall said she has lodged a complaint to the Solicitor General’s office against the officer who issued the order to fill the groundhog hole











































